The relationship started when Jeter was a rookie for the Yankees, on the verge of winning his first World Championship.
Carey was also at the top of her game, releasing the albums The current wife of Nick Lachey, Vanessa Minnillo formerly dated Jeter back in 2003.
When you are a legend in your sport, you get rewarded with millions of dollars - and a revolving door of hot girlfriends.
We have seen Jeter with numerous ladies that we expected - and often hoped - he would finally settle down with. Jeter and Dutta were spotted together shortly after she won the 2000 Miss Universe Pageant. Dutta is one of the bigger stars in her native India courtesy of roles in Bollywood hits such as "Om Shanti Om" and "Billu Barber" which many of you may have seen.
At the time Minnillo was hosting MTV's "Total Request Live" and was a former Miss Teen USA.
Sports Illustrated Swimsuit model Hannah Davis and former New York Yankees shortstop Derek Jeter married in an intimate ceremony at the Meadowood Napa Valley Resort in California on Saturday, according to PEOPLE.
Hannah and Derek have been dating for over three years, but started appearing together at red carpet events last summer.
Every time the public has come to expect him to finally have found the 'one,' we get another one of those breakup tabloids. Many of you may remember the name Rachel Uchitel from the Tiger Woods saga. Jeter and Uchitel spent time together back in 2008.
Uchitel was rumored to appear for Jeter and Enriquez briefly dated back in 2001, after Alex Rodriquez supposedly introduced the two following his own relationship with the star.
Enriquez is an actress and singer who has appeared in the television series This was one of Jeter's longer relationships, lasting from 1996-1998 with the diva.Jeter and Carey were the first high-profile pairing in a train of many for Jeter.